
When a gaming company apologises, does it rebuild trust or simply protect its reputation? The same statement can reassure one player and make another roll their eyes. Stuart Hall’s encoding and decoding model helps explain why audiences can understand a message while disagreeing about what it means.
Hall (1973) argues that producers encode media messages within particular frameworks of meaning. Audiences then decode them through their own social experiences and cultural backgrounds. Producers can encourage a preferred interpretation, but they cannot guarantee that audiences will accept it. This makes communication a process involving power and interpretation, rather than simply sending information to passive receivers.
A useful example is the apology published before the launch of Star Wars Battlefront II in 2017. In a statement hosted by EA, DICE acknowledged concerns that in-game purchases could give players unfair advantages and announced that purchases would temporarily be switched off (Gabrielson, 2017). The statement emphasised listening, improving the experience and responding to the community.
I would interpret its preferred message as: we care about players and are taking responsibility. However, applying Hall’s three audience positions suggests different ways of reading that message. These are possible interpretations, rather than claims that every player responded in one of these ways.
A dominant-hegemonic reading would accept the statement’s framing. A player might see the decision as evidence that the company values feedback and deserves another chance.
A negotiated reading would broadly accept the apology while making exceptions based on personal experience. Someone might welcome the change but decide to wait for reviews before buying the game. They accept that improvements are happening without immediately restoring their trust.
An oppositional reading would understand the intended reassurance but interpret it through a different framework. A player might view the apology as reputation management, seeing commercial pressure as the reason for the change. This is more than disliking the statement: it challenges the company’s explanation of its relationship with players. Hall’s distinction matters because opposition can involve understanding a message perfectly well and rejecting its assumptions.
For me, gaming makes this theory relatable because my enthusiasm for a game can exist alongside distrust of its publisher. Previous experiences with disappointing releases or additional purchases could influence how someone reads another promise.
However, audiences being active does not make producers powerless. The company still chooses the wording and frames the response. Hall’s model encourages us to examine both sides: how organisations try to establish meaning, and how audiences accept, adapt or challenge it.
References
Gabrielson, O. (2017) ‘An update on Star Wars Battlefront II’. EA. Available here (Accessed: 15 November 2026).
Hall, S. (1973) Encoding and decoding in the television discourse. Birmingham: University of Birmingham. Available here (Accessed: 15 November 2026).
