Come on Barbie, let’s decode? Stuart Hall and his theory

Last time I watched a film with friends, we walked out of the cinema with completely different opinions. One movie and whole different scale of views. Stuart Hall’s idea of encoding and decoding explains why.

Hall argued that media makers “encode” meaning. They build messages from their own ideas, their industry’s habits and the dominant values of their society. Audiences then “decode” those messages, and there is no guarantee they will take away the meaning the makers intended (Hall, 2006, p. XX). He described three ways of reading: 1) A dominant reading accepts the intended meaning. 2)A negotiated reading accepts some of it and questions the rest. 3) An oppositional reading understands the intended meaning but rejects it (Hall, 2006, p. XX).

A good example is Barbie (Gerwig, 2023). It was made by a major studio with the toy company Mattel involved, and it was promoted as a funny story about identity and empowerment. Some viewers read it as intended, as a feminist message. Others read it in a negotiated way. They enjoyed it, but noticed it also sells dolls. Others read it oppositionally and saw a toy advert dressed up as feminism. All three groups watched the same film.

This is different from the culture industry view I wrote about earlier, where audiences seem to take what they are given. Hall gives audiences more power. People bring their own background, culture and experience when they decode (Hall, 2006, p. XX).

I usually decode in a negotiated way. I can enjoy a film and still notice who made it and why. I want to become a creative director, so this matters to me in practice. When you create something, you make encoding choices about colour, story and tone, but you can’t control how people decode it.

Hall’s model has limits. He was writing about television in the 1970s, and today audiences answer back publicly with memes, reaction videos and comments, so decoding is much more visible. Real viewers also mix positions, so three neat categories can be too simple.

So when a film is made to be read in one way, 
whose reading counts, the maker’s or the audience’s?

1 thought on “Come on Barbie, let’s decode? Stuart Hall and his theory”

  1. I like how this article utilises Barbie in explaining Stuart Hall’s encoding and decoding theory, given how accessible it makes the theory. This highlights the fact that everyone interprets the same media in different ways due to their own experiences and perceptions, thus making the audience as relevant as the media creators.

Leave a Reply