Have you ever seen an advert on the TV that made you roll your eyes while your friend thought it was genius? Or read a headline that seemed perfectly innocent to you but controversial to someone else? Hall provides us with an explanation as to why we don’t all see media the same.
In his influential 1980 chapter, Encoding/Decoding, Stuart Hall challenges the idea that media messages are simply created by producers and passively absorbed by audiences. Instead, he argues that communication is a process in which the meanings are first encoded by media producers and later decoded by audiences. Producers construct their specific messages using cultural values and beliefs, but audiences interpret them through their own social perspectives.
Now here’s where things get very interesting: the message intended isn’t necessarily the message received. Why? The producer cannot determine which decoding codes will be employed.
Therefore, Stuart Hall offers a hypothetical analysis of some possible decoding positions of a televisual message, that are some possible and different ways to interpret a message. He breaks these up into three possible audience positions. The dominant-hegemonic reading occurs when audiences accept the preferred meaning intended by the producer. A negotiated reading happens when they broadly accept the message but adapt or personally question certain aspects of it. Finally, an oppositional reading occurs when audiences understand the intended message but simply reject it, interpreting it through their own alternative viewpoint.
For example, in a luxury fashion advert a designer brand might encode an image of an expensive handbag as a symbol of confidence and success. While one viewer might completely buy into this intended message and see the handbag as the ultimate status symbol, another might appreciate the campaign’s aesthetic but question the ridiculous overpriced tag. Meanwhile, someone else might interpret it as simply a celebration of consumerism and unrealistic wealth. Three people, one advert, and three entirely different meanings are resulted out of this luxury fashion advert.
Hall’s theory can be particularly relevant in today’s social media culture. A brand might spend thousands creating the perfect campaign, only for TikTok or Instagram users to turn it into a meme, criticise its message or give it an entirely new meaning. Audiences are no longer simply receiving media; they are actively participating in how it is interpreted.
Overall, Hall reminds us that media producers may have control over the messages they create, however, cannot control every interpretation. In the current world where everyone has their own opinion and even a platform to share it, the most interesting part of a media message isn’t what was originally intended to be put forward, but rather what audiences make of it in the end.
References:
Hall, S. (1980) ‘Encoding/decoding’, in Hall, S., Hobson, D., Lowe, A. and Willis, P. (eds.) Culture, Media, Language. London: Hutchinson
Viviani, I. (2017) ‘Stuart Hall’, BrixenLabs, 9 May
