Creative or destruction? Decoding the Apple “Crush!” advertisment

In 2024, Tim Cook post an advertisement video for iPad Pro, this video attracted considerable criticism and negative reactions. In the video a huge hydraulic press crushed art objects, including paints and musical instrument. Then an iPad Pro appear when the press rise (Apple, 2024). Apple intended to demonstrate the iPad creative capabilities, and it can support different kinds of art creation. However, numbers of audience think this video means iPad or technology may destroy art. So, why the same image shows different means for different people?

Hall’s encoding/ decoding model shows producers encode meaning they want audience to accept into the media content, while audience decoding the message through their culture and social environment. Hall identifies three decoding positions: dominant-hegemonic, which accepts the preferred meaning; negotiated, which accepts its broad framework but adapts it to circumstances; and oppositional, which understands the preferred meaning but interprets the message through an alternative framework (Hall, 2006). Therefor, Encoding cannot guarantee that audiences interpretations will match the meaning intended by producer.

In this video, musical instruments, cameras and paints represent different creative activities. Placing these objects beneath the hydraulic press can be interpreted as suggesting that the iPad integrates many different forms of creation. The iPad’s appearance at the end connects these creative capabilities with the product. Furthermore, Tim Cook emphasised creation when sharing the video. Apple therefore intended the advertisement to communicate that the iPad offers more possibilities for creative work.

However, some viewers decoded the act of crushing as destruction and interpreted the advertisement as depicting the destruction of art. The crushed instruments and artistic materials became symbols of human culture being destroyed by technology. This is a kind of oppositional decoding, while the hydraulic press is the sign of technology companies, which is destroying culture. Diverse form of art is replaced by art. Audience interpret images through different culture and social environment, so producer cannot make sure every audience accept the meaning they want them to accept.

This advertisement and its comments show that audience won’t always understand the meanings the brand want they understand, but this doesn’t mean they are wrong. Same video could seem as the integration of creative, but also as technology replacing art. Audience can actively take part in the construction of meaning, so brands cannot fully control their advertisements mean.

Reference

Cook, T. (2024) ‘Meet the new iPad Pro’ [Video], X, 7 May. Available at: https://x.com/tim_cook/status/1787864325258162239 (Accessed: 15 November 2026).

Hall, S. (2006) ‘Encoding/Decoding’, in Durham, M.G. and Kellner, D.M. (eds.) Media and Cultural Studies: Keyworks. Revised edn. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 163–173.

Leave a Reply